250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton NC
- 5 Bed
- 3 Bath
- 2317 ft2
- 0.8 ac
For Sale $435,000
Remarks:
Welcome to the "Hill House" a Rutherfordton property with a distinctive character, generous space, and a layout that invites you to create something truly your own. Known in the community as the Hill House, this substantial brick home offers just under 3,500 sq ft of finished living space, plus an additional 325 sq ft enclosed porch that is not included in the heated square footage. You will find 2317 sq ft on the main level, along with 1172 sq ft of finished basement living and an additional 1211 sq ft of unfinished area. More than just a home, this is an opportunity to take a unique property and transform it into a one-of-a-kind personal retreat. The main level features the kitchen with ample cabinet and counter space, breakfast area, dining room, and an oversized living room with a brick fireplace and built-ins. A room with cabinetry just off the foyer and across from the kitchen offers excellent potential for a walk-in pantry, mudroom, or additional storage. The primary bedroom and second bedroom feature a unique arrangement with two en-suite bathrooms sharing a walk-in shower. A third bedroom has the perfect ability to serve as a home office, with a separate laundry room offering additional cabinetry and storage. The full walk-out basement includes two additional bedrooms, a full bathroom, and a family room, with approximately half of the basement finished and plenty of room to expand. With its separate access and existing layout, the lower level offers exciting potential for a private guest suite or additional living quarters. Recent improvements include two Trane heat pumps and air handlers installed in 2021, a tankless water heater installed in 2022, and an owned propane tank for the gas fireplace logs. Outside, enjoy the covered front porch, deck, vinyl-fenced area ideal for play or pets, expanded driveway, two-car garage with large storage room, and a 20x12 storage building with additional 10x12 lean-to storage. Located conveniently near Rutherford Regional Hospital, Downtown Rutherfordton, recreation, walking trails, and Crestview Park. This is a home with character, space, and endless possibilities to customize, and ready for your personal vision.
Interior Features:
Pantry, Walk-In Closet(s), Walk-In Pantry
General Information:
| List Price: | $435,000 |
| Status: | For Sale |
| Bedrooms: | 5 |
| Type: | Single Family Residence |
| Approx Sq. Ft.: | 2317 sqft |
| Parking: | Driveway, Attached Garage, Garage Door Opener, Garage Faces Rear |
| MLS Number: | CAR4421713 |
| Subdivision: | Hillcrest |
| Bathrooms: | 3 |
| Year Built: | 1987 |
| Sewer Type: | Public Sewer |
Assigned Schools:
| Elementary: | Rutherfordton |
| Middle: | RS |
| High: | R-S Central |
Price & Sales History
| Date | Event | Price | $/SQFT |
| 09-24-2026 | Listed | $435,000 | $188 |
| 02-06-2026 | Price Decrease | $400,000-3.38% | $173 |
| 01-23-2026 | Price Decrease | $414,000-1.19% | $179 |
| 01-09-2026 | Price Decrease | $419,000-1.41% | $181 |
| 12-18-2025 | Listed | $425,000 | $184 |
Nearby Schools
These schools are only nearby your property search, you must confirm exact assigned schools.
| School Name | Distance | Grades | Rating |
| Rutherfordton Elementary School | 2 miles | PK-05 | 7 |
| Spindale Elementary School | 2 miles | PK-05 | 6 |
| Mt. Vernon-Ruth Elementary School | 5 miles | PK-05 | 5 |
| Forest City-Dunbar Elementary School | 5 miles | PK-05 | 4 |
| Harris Elementary School | 6 miles | PK-05 | 7 |
| Forrest W. Hunt Elementary School | 7 miles | PK-05 | 8 |
Source is provided by local and state governments and municipalities and is subject to change without notice, and is not guaranteed to be up to date or accurate.
Properties For Sale Nearby
Mileage is an estimation calculated from the property results address of your search. Driving time will vary from location to location.
| Street Address | Distance | Status | List Price | Days on Market |
| 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton NC | 0 mi | $435,000 | days | |
| 268 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton NC | 0 mi | $240,000 | days | |
| 275 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton NC | 0.1 mi | $299,000 | days | |
| 106 Freeman Street, Rutherfordton NC | 0.1 mi | $259,900 | days | |
| 170 Hodge Street, Rutherfordton NC | 0.1 mi | $315,000 | days | |
| 326 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton NC | 0.1 mi | $254,900 | days |
Sold Properties Nearby
Mileage is an estimation calculated from the property results address of your search. Driving time will vary from location to location.
| Street Address | Distance | Property Type | Sold Price | Property Details |
Commute Distance & Time
Powered by Google Maps
Mortgage Calculator
| Down Payment Amount | $990,000 |
| Mortgage Amount | $3,960,000 |
| Monthly Payment (Principal & Interest Only) | $19,480 |
* Expand Calculator (incl. monthly expenses)
| Property Taxes |
$
|
| H.O.A. / Maintenance |
$
|
| Property Insurance |
$
|
| Total Monthly Payment | $20,941 |
Demographic Data For Zip 28139
|
Occupancy Types |
|
Transportation to Work |
Source is provided by local and state governments and municipalities and is subject to change without notice, and is not guaranteed to be up to date or accurate.
Property Listing Information
A Courtesy Listing Provided By Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Elite Properties
250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton NC is a 2317 ft2 on a 0.750 acres Appraisal lot. This is for $435,000. This has 5 bedrooms, 3 baths, and was built in 1987.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2026-09-24 04:15:27 EST. All data is
obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied
Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently
reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent
presenting the information. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.
Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS.
Click here for more information
Neither Yates Realty nor any listing broker shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints, and they shall be held totally harmless from any damages arising from reliance upon this data. This data is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties they may be interested in purchasing.
